BIKEPGH MESSAGE BOARD ARCHIVE

« Back to Archive
36

Need your help with editing bridge descriptions for bike map

We're working on the next version of the bike map, and one of the last things to do is to re write the bridge descriptions. I need to trim the fat so-to-speak and make the descriptions shorter and more succinct.


I'm having some trouble with the Rankin Bridge and the West End Bridge.


The Rankin Bridge was just re-done, and honestly, I'm not aware of all of the subtleties of riding across it now.


And this is what the current map says for the West End Bridge:

Description: This is a hairy bridge to ride in traffic. However, there is sidewalk access on each side, but it is hard to get to and find without climbing a concrete barrier in traffic or getting off your bike and climbing stairs. On the road: two lanes each direction, no shoulder, with bike unfriendly expansion gaps. Entering from East Carson is sketchy as you have to navigate near the West End Circle. Entering from West Carson is even sketchier as you have to go around the circle. Recommended Route: the southbound sidewalk. From East Carson, when it splits, DO NOT follow the signs to the West End Bridge. Instead, bear right under the bridge, and you will come upon a staircase to take you up to the path on the bridge. This will let you out onto the intersection at Western Ave where you can take the street. From Western Ave, North Side, enter the sidewalk on the NORTHBOUND side of the bridge. A path will take you under the bridge and up to the Southbound sidewalk. From here, you must descend the steps to go east, or continue West on Carson street. To go east, you must ride the sidewalk for a few blocks, then you can pick up the Station square trail by making a left at the light or ride East Carson St. Things to look out for: Other than fast cars, debris, expansion gaps, and sketchy enter/exit, see description.


Yikes!


Does anyone ride this frequently enough to help me get this down to like 3 or 4 sentences?


If anyone feels like fact checking the complete live document, go right ahead: http://docs.google.com/View?id=dgcqknb4_16f97vn6vb


erok
2011-06-07 14:34:07

The Rankin bridge now has wide shoulders and a narrow sidewalk on one side.


rsprake
2011-06-07 14:43:36

How does it "feel" now? on a scale of 1-10, 10 being the safest. I seriously never ride this bridge.


erok
2011-06-07 14:46:28

the shoulders are ample on the rankin bridge, almost a full lane width but it has common issues with gravel and glass accumulation.


dmtroyer
2011-06-07 14:48:27

Maybe a 7 depending on the day and time. It's sort of like the Forbes Ave bike lane. The shoulder gets you out of the way.


rsprake
2011-06-07 15:04:23

Erok, not really a fact thing, but more of a trim the fat type thing:

Words like "fairly", "pretty", "really", "very", "especially", and "generally" could be eliminated in most of the descriptions and have the meaning stay the same.


dwillen
2011-06-07 15:05:05

The Smithfield Street Bridge description says "sidewalk on the southbound side is for mixed-use pedestrian/cyclists". I believe the northbound (upstream) side is so designated (though it might be both).


It might be better to use consistent bridge sidewalk terminology, not a mix of upstream, northbound, and inbound.


Also, the Highland Park Bridge description uses "out-bound", with an unneeded hyphen.


steven
2011-06-07 15:10:10

Good points. Thanks, this is exactly the help i was looking for. You're right it is the northbound side.


erok
2011-06-07 15:19:59

Maybe revised Rankin Bridge text, or at least a starting point (compiling what everyone else has already said):


The Rankin Bridge features a sidewalk on the Whitaker-to-Rankin side of the bridge. On both sides, the shoulders are wide and offer lots of space, although gravel and glass can accumulate.




alucas
2011-06-07 15:20:14

I ride the west end bridge most every day (except for recently as I am currently injured and can't ride) and I just take the street. I come from Crafton usually close to 9 am, through the circle and just proceed forward onto the bridge roadway. I really haven't had any problems with traffic that were any differant than what one would expect on any other road with a high volume of fast moving (read law breaking) traffic. That being said, on a scary scale of 1-10 I'd rate it a 6 or 7, and I consider myself pretty fearless on 2 wheels. I don't usually ride home across the west end bridge from north to south because although it's faster, the climb from Western Ave. to the bridge deck slows me down too much to safely merge with the traffic merging from rt. 65 on the right. Sorry I know this doesn't exactly help you narrow your description of the bridge, just thought it might help you understand what an average commuter might experience trying to ford the mighty Ohio river at that particular spot.


chefjohn
2011-06-07 15:27:43

Cool,

to stay consistent with how the rest are written, how's this for Rankin:


Medium speed traffic with wide shoulders that may accumulate debris. Sidewalk on the northbound side. Enter/exit bridge with caution.


erok
2011-06-07 15:30:36

thanks chefjohn, that is helpful


erok
2011-06-07 15:31:35

Rankin bridge description sounds good Erok.


rsprake
2011-06-07 15:38:42

Is this someone trying to walk across traffic in front of a huge truck on the mckees rocks bridge?

Link to google street view


erok
2011-06-07 15:51:34

That pedestrian certainly conforms to PennDOT's multimodal goals, yes?


sloaps
2011-06-07 16:21:18

it's definitely a complete street.


erok
2011-06-07 17:43:30

erok what can you do about keeping the 31st

street bridge from connecting to 28 forever?


steevo
2011-06-07 18:09:10



wojty
2011-06-07 19:02:08

On a more serious note, I talked to a couple 'island residents' at red fin blues not too long ago who all said they enjoyed the way the bridge is. They can get out much faster, are usually going downtown, or don't find 31st -> 40th -> 28 that bad compared to the annoyingly long light they had to wait for before.


wojty
2011-06-07 19:03:51

What Steevo just said. Seriously.


I'm sure someone benefits from it being connected to 28, but who? Those lights screw up everything for everyone. Without them things are so much nicer.


I guess if you wanted to get from Rialto (when it's not closed for the winter) to the 31st St Bridge you're screwed. But how many people does that really affect?


alucas
2011-06-07 19:07:51

I thought the final plan was to have 28 go under the bridge, and you'd have to exit to get onto 31st st. i could be wrong


erok
2011-06-07 19:50:16

The best/shortest I could come up with for the west end bridge:



The roadway is two lanes each direction, no shoulders and traffic moves at highway speeds. There are walkways on both the northbound and southbound sides of the bridge. From the North Side, both walkways can be accessed from a walkway on the northbound side of the bridge or from a set of stairs on the corner of North Point Dr and Belmont St. Access to the northbound walkway requires the use of stairs from either approach. From the West End, both walkways can be accessed from stairs on the sidewalk of the lower portion of W. Carson Street. Alternatively, both walkways can be accessed from the West End Circle, northbound with a crosswalk and sidewalk from S. Main St / Rt 51 and southbound with a crosswalk and sidewalk from Steuben St.


It's still a bit longer than 2-3 sentences, but there is a lot going on with that bridge.


I personally take the walkway as I don't have ferrous gonads like chefjon. The last time I took the road over that bridge was the scariest experience I have ever had on a bike. It was the day after the biggest snowstorm of this year and I decided to cross the WEB after slipping and falling on the ice near the smithfield st. bridge. The west end circle was fine, but the bridge was covered in rough, icy crud that made for a bumpy ride. As I was bouncing down the far end of the bridge at ~17mph when a car passed me on the left at ~50mph and cut hard in front of me. He began sliding out and narrowly missed slamming into the divider on the ramp towards downtown. I was too busy keeping myself from bouncing off the bike to sh*t myself. I avoided that bridge entirely for the rest of the winter.


cuse
2011-06-07 20:05:13

How is this(?):


Fast moving traffic with no shoulder. Sidewalks on both sides. Sidewalk on northbound side requires use of stairs at each end. Access the sidewalk from the north on Western Ave or from stairs at North Point Dr/Belmont St. Access the sidewalk from the south from stairs on W. Carson St or from the West End Circle at either S. Main St / Rt 51 or Steuben St.


erok
2011-06-07 21:21:10

btw thanks cuse that was really helpful


erok
2011-06-07 21:21:27

I might add this line:

Fast moving traffic with no shoulder. West End Circle is very confusing and dangerous. Sidewalks on both sides. Sidewalk on northbound side requires use of stairs at each end. Access the sidewalk from the north on Western Ave or from stairs at North Point Dr/Belmont St. Access the sidewalk from the south from stairs on W. Carson St or from the West End Circle at either S. Main St / Rt 51 or Steuben St.


erok
2011-06-07 21:24:35

-very


dwillen
2011-06-07 21:25:25

fat is trimmed


erok
2011-06-07 21:49:20

Bloody West End Bridge...


Note that the "sidewalk" is very narrow and tight. I ride that bridge more often then I'd like. Rode the road once, which was an adversarial and contentious adventure in just getting on the damned bridge. I've hewed to the sidewalk since. Traveling west on the north sidewalk coming down the crest one picks up some speed, but at the end, a signal switching box juts out abruptly before the hidden sharp turn onto Carson's vague impersonation of a sidewalk, and it is always littered with debris. Still, it's the only way to get from here to there, provides nice views, and is spitting distance from Pgh Police's elite Accident Investigation Unit...


fungicyclist
2011-06-07 21:56:54

Erok, that last description looks great go with it.


chefjohn
2011-06-08 15:34:36

@erok: Slightly OT, but is there any chance for a change in font or type size for readability on street names? Even removing the outline from the names of the recommended routes would help a lot.


pseudacris
2011-06-08 16:54:20

That is the idea. that was probably our #1 complaint. I haven't seen the final product yet tho.


erok
2011-06-09 19:59:37

Found a few typos:

62nd SB: site/sight;

Smithfield: Furness/Furnace;

Bloomfield: Milvale/Millvale, + I bet that's Beethoven but didn't check it.


Hot Metal Bridge could you add something about taking the corners slowly on the side-access ramp-thing I am always anticipating collisons there.


YES PLEASE to the larger/bolder font on the street names, I love the map, if the names were easier to read it would be totally perfect. Title Case might help.


Does anyone know what the plan is for the goat path from Millvale to 40SB?


naomi
2011-06-10 01:59:41

It really is Bethoven St. Always struck me as odd, but that's what the signs say.


lyle
2011-06-10 12:15:54

I've heard the name comes from BETH[lehem Steel] OVEN. Polish Hill old timers pronounce it that way,too.


pseudacris
2011-06-10 18:28:25

thanks for finding the typos. Bethoven is def correct tho, and pseudacris is right, it's actually pronounced Beth-Oven


We are looking into title case as well.


erok
2011-06-11 12:44:54

Also, I can't believe i typed "furness" instead of "furnace." Furness is the last name of a friend of mine, and he would have thought it was hilarious that i messed it up because his last name slipped into my head.


erok
2011-06-11 12:51:32