BIKEPGH MESSAGE BOARD ARCHIVE

« Back to Archive
6

SciAm: Particulate Inhalation while Riding

Another interesting Scientific American article on urban cycling

This one is about diesel (and other) exhausts and the particulates and gases we're all breathing in every day, and even more than usual because we're breathing heavier while we bike.

Probably the best summary sentence:

Though Australian researchers found that exposure to these pollutants is actually higher while riding inside a vehicle than while riding a bike, turning your handlebars in the direction of back roads might still be a good idea, for safety’s sake, as well.


I'm not hugely impressed with the article, personally, but then again it's more of a blog-type thing and not meant to stand up to any kind of scientific rigor. I guess their main advice is "sticking to less-trafficked roads wouldn't be a bad idea, for your lungs' sake," and I can't disagree with that. But I'm also really curious what their evidence (metals in tree leaves) means for pedestrians. Is it worse for peds because they're spending longer on the road to walk between the same two places? Or do most people not walk as far as people would bike?


Anyway, just thought I'd share the article and see what discussion comes of it. Local pollution being bad for you is no surprise to any of us, but I don't often think about it while biking until I get stuck behind a bus.


alnilam
2010-01-18 16:56:42

Hmmm...

Even as a blog post, I find it lacking.


Just one example: is the level of magnetic material in trees a valid or recognized method of asessing pollution? In the article it sounds like an "Oh Wow!" project from a geophysicist that might be a good idea (or might not), but hasn't been well-characterized.


I've heard debate as to whether jogging in high=-pollution areas is healthy. IIRC, the bottom line was that the pollution isn't good for you, but exercise is so beneficial, that if , say, you live in NYC, you are better jogging in poor air than not jogging.


Mick


mick
2010-01-18 20:17:56

Pretty much my thoughts exactly.


alnilam
2010-01-18 20:46:46

THIS JUST IN!

Scientists discover that cars are bad for the earth


spakbros
2010-01-18 23:01:06

this just in, breathing in fumes is not super awesome. lets go do intervals on the jail trail at 5pm


steevo
2010-01-18 23:11:31

that new car smell is V.O.C.'s.


sloaps
2010-01-18 23:29:09